H&R Block vs TaxSlayer

Compare H&R Block and TaxSlayer for 2025 tax filing. See pricing, features, support options, and which software is best for your budget and tax situation.

5
H&R Block wins
1
Ties
4
TaxSlayer wins

H&R Block

A trusted tax brand combining polished online software with 12,000+ physical offices. Offers competitive pricing, strong guidance, and the unique ability to get in-person help at any stage of filing.

TaxSlayer

An affordable tax software known for speed and value. Covers all major tax situations from simple W-2 returns to complex self-employment at prices well below the major brands.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

CategoryH&R BlockTaxSlayerWinner
Free TierSimple returns with more form supportSimple W-2 returns only
Deluxe/Classic Price$55 federal + $49 per state$22.95 federal + $39.95 per state
Self-Employed Price$85 federal + $49 per state$52.95 federal + $39.95 per state
In-Person Support12,000+ offices nationwideOnline and phone only
User InterfaceClean, modern interview-style guidanceEfficient and fast; less hand-holding
Data ImportGood import from employers and financial institutionsBasic W-2 import; fewer integrations
Military SupportFree for military through some promotionsFree federal filing for active duty military
Filing SpeedThorough process; moderate speedFast filing experience
Audit SupportFree support; full representation with paid tiersAvailable with Premium tier ($42.95)
Mobile AppFull-featured native appGood native app

The Verdict

H&R Block offers a better overall package with superior guidance, in-person offices, and more comprehensive support. TaxSlayer saves $25-$40 per filing while covering the same forms and maintaining accuracy. For confident filers who prioritize speed and savings, TaxSlayer is excellent. For those wanting more support and a polished experience, H&R Block justifies the premium.

Choose H&R Block if...

Filers who want in-person support as a safety net, those who prefer more detailed guidance, and anyone who values the ability to start online and finish at a physical office.

Choose TaxSlayer if...

Active duty military, experienced filers who know their tax situation, and anyone who wants fast filing at the lowest possible cost without sacrificing form support.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is TaxSlayer as reliable as H&R Block?
Yes. TaxSlayer has been an IRS-authorized e-file provider for over 25 years and processes millions of returns annually. Both guarantee accuracy and offer audit support. The difference is in the experience and support options, not reliability.
Can TaxSlayer handle rental property and investments?
Yes. TaxSlayer Classic ($22.95) supports Schedule D for investments and Schedule E for rental income. H&R Block covers these in their Premium tier ($85). TaxSlayer offers significant savings for these common situations.
Which is better for someone who has never filed before?
H&R Block is better for first-time filers due to its more detailed guidance, contextual explanations, and the option to visit a physical office if you get stuck. TaxSlayer moves faster but assumes more tax knowledge.
Does TaxSlayer offer any in-person options?
No. TaxSlayer is entirely online. If in-person support is important to you, H&R Block is the only major software provider with a nationwide network of physical offices.

More Comparisons